“I ate and drank excessively in vain, was dissolute in vain, ran about in vain.”
J. G. Hamann, recalling London (1758), as quoted in K. R. Hagenbach, German Rationalism (1865), p. 269, trans. Gage & Stuckenberg, public domain.public domain
In Vain
SpiritualityArgument · power 80 · 100% accurateIn the gameLondon, 1757. Hamann was sent on a firm’s business, failed at it and spent the money on pleasure. He looked back on those months with the Preacher’s word: in vain.
Strong against
×2.5The Man of the Worldan argument · why?
Hamann lived the man of the world’s life in London, with money that was not his, and called every part of it vain. Pleasure did not satisfy him; Christ did.
“The more I read it, … the newer the Word of God seemed to me”
J. G. Hamann, of London in 1758, as quoted in K. R. Hagenbach, German Rationalism (1865), p. 269, trans. Gage & Stuckenberg, public domain.public domain
The More I Read
ExegesisArgument · power 84 · 100% accurateIn the gameMarch 1758. Alone in a London lodging with nothing left, Hamann began reading the Bible from the beginning, and kept going.
“I found the unity of the Divine will in the redemption by Jesus Christ, and that all history, all miracles, and all the laws and worlds of God meet in this centre”
J. G. Hamann, of London in 1758, as quoted in K. R. Hagenbach, German Rationalism (1865), p. 270, trans. Gage & Stuckenberg, public domain.public domain
All History Meets Here
ChristologyArgument · power 88 · 100% accurateIn the gameWhat Hamann found when he had read the whole Bible: it is one story, and its centre is Christ. Cut out the miracles and the rest no longer holds together.
Strong against
×2.5The Razored Biblean argument · why?
Hamann read the whole Bible and found the miracles and the history meet in one centre, the redemption by Christ. Cut the miracles out and the teaching loses what it was about.
×2.5The Ugly Broad Ditchan argument · why?
Lessing said history can never carry eternal truth. Hamann found that God chose to speak through history, and that all of it meets in Christ.
“my heart is calmer than ever before in my life.”
J. G. Hamann, after his conversion (1758), as quoted in K. R. Hagenbach, German Rationalism (1865), p. 270, trans. Gage & Stuckenberg, public domain.public domain
Calmer Than Ever
SpiritualityStat shift · 100% accurateIn the gameHamann, after his conversion, with no money and no prospects: for the first time in his life he was at peace. Raises the reader’s own Defend.
“But scientific books seem now like Job’s friends, better suited to task my patience,”
J. G. Hamann, Biblical Meditations (London, 1758), as quoted in J. M. Hoppin, “John George Hamann,” Bibliotheca Sacra 17 (1860), p. 315, public domain.public domain
Job’s Friends
ExegesisArgument · power 82 · 100% accurateIn the gameFrom the Biblical Meditations Hamann wrote in London in 1758. Once he had the Bible, the learned books he had loved seemed to talk a great deal and comfort nobody.